Three Man Band
Story based on the nightmare I had on 4/27/20 after reading The Guest List by Lucy Foley.
I wasn’t sure of the time as we stepped out the back door of our apartment complex. It was newly dark, with still a glint of purple in the sky. The warm summer breeze brushed over my face as I stepped down into the soggy grass. I could see our destination ahead of us, what appeared to be an old marquee with a beautiful forest back drop. The thought struck me that we should be grateful to have this in our own backyard.
The closer we got, I realized the structure was made entirely of metal. It wasn’t comprised of a shiny stainless steel, but more of an old, flimsy tin. The blue-gray color had long been worn away and a green algae film stuck to almost every surface. Where there wasn’t any algae, there was rust. The combination of the two seemed to suck every ounce of life from the structure. As we approached, I took in the details of what I initially thought was a marquee.
Slowly, my brain processed what was actually an old theatrical set. It was almost as if I was looking into a dollhouse that was missing the face of its house. There was a tiny living room to the right, defined by right and rear exterior walls. The rear wall stood opposite of us and was the only support that ran the length of the structure. To the left, the living room opened up into a small kitchen. It was so run down that the only indicator that it was once a kitchen was an old stove that sat center. My hand reached out to touch one of the algae-covered burners but stopped midair. Something in my brain warned me against it, as if the whole kitchen would crumble under my fingertips.
Finally, on the lefthand side of the kitchen was what seemed to be a third room, the only part of the set that was surrounded by its own four walls. It looked so out of place, so closed off and private from the rest of the set—maybe it was a bathroom? A swinging door was the only way in or out, which I didn’t find weird upon principle. What I did find weird though, was that this swinging saloon door was made out of fresh wood—cedar, was it? It contrasted so sharply against the rest of the deteriorating building—how did I not notice this initially?
“Wow what do you think that was used for?” I jumped in response to the sound of her voice. I had completely forgotten that my mom had walked out here with me. I spun around to see what she meant. About 50 yards behind me was a set of small wooden bleachers. They weren’t very large at all, maybe able to seat 20 people at most. Like the saloon door, these bleachers were made of newer wood, but shoddily held together by rusty nails that stuck out in every direction. Cement walls framed three sides of the bleachers, with a chain-link fence as the front and fourth wall. It gave the impression that any spectators of this theater set didn’t have the choice of leaving after the show was over.
I felt a chill roll down my spine, the summer breeze didn’t feel so warm and fuzzy anymore. Behind the bleachers I could see the looming outline of the building that neighbored our apartment complex. I had heard rumors that it was an old psychiatric hospital but couldn’t remember ever seeing anyone come in or out of its doors. I turned to my left and walked over to where my mom was sitting. It was a brand-new picnic table off of the living room—by far the friendliest of the seating options here. As I took a seat the wind picked up, causing the set to sway and moan at its joints. I waited for the wind to die down, as it normally would after a gust, but it only grew with intensity. What was first a moan from the structure turned into an ear-piercing screech. The metal began grinding together, screaming in discomfort.
Distracted by the violence of the set, I didn’t notice a light turn on in the enclosed room. It wasn’t until I heard a cackle above the wind that my attention turned to it. To my ears it sounded inhuman, but I quickly realized it was reverberating from the man that was now stepping out from behind the saloon door. Suddenly, everything went quiet. The wind halted and along with it, the howling.
“Well, what do we have here? Haven’t seen you two ‘round before! Boys, come take a look at this!” Behind him, two more men stepped out of the tiny room—how did they all fit in there? They seemed friendly enough, all smiles and easy body language as they walked over to where we were sitting. Something seemed off though, once again I received a warning signal from my brain. There was something predator about their demeanor, maybe it was that their smiles showed just a little too much teeth. I stood up as they sat around the picnic table, it was like I suddenly had this primal instinct to go back inside the apartment building, to run as far away from here as I could—that’s what prey does, it runs. I didn’t run though, I stayed put as they all began to make small talk. The men seemed wild, yipping back and forth to one another, howling with laughter. I had trouble focusing on what they were saying, all I could think was—they seem more like wolves than humans. It’s not long before I was snapped to attention at mention of the building next door, “—finally escaped from that looney bin! Boy is it nice to finally meet some neighbors.”
“Wait wha—” I started to choke.
“Like a light?” The first gentleman interrupted me and held out a pack of American Spirits to my mom—whatever you do, don’t accept one. I stood painfully silent, as my mom lit up a cigarette. I knew that I needed to knock it out of her hand, tell her not to take a drag, but instead I stood there frozen. I watched as her eyes glazed over, “God, that’s good.”
There was a banging back behind us at the apartment building and three of our neighbors—God, what were their names—stepped out into the yard. The three women walked over towards us, like it was the most normal thing in the world, us sitting there with those three men. Without hesitation or a word likewise, the women each accepted a cigarette—Jesus fucking Christ, how do they not know…and who’s watching their children? Once again, I watched silently as all of their eyes glazed over.
It wasn’t long before all of the women were yipping along, howling at the moon in perfect harmony with the men. I didn’t know how much time had passed, as I stood there unable to move or talk, but the darkness felt like it was starting to swallow me up. At last the first man stood and hushed all conversation.
“Well, I believe it’s time for us to start playin’ some tunes! What do you ladies think? You’re gonna love our band!” The two other men stood up and followed him back into that tiny room, carelessly swinging back that cedar saloon door. In a matter of seconds, the screeching was back. That relentless wind picked back up and I covered my ears to help drown out the blood curdling noise, but I couldn’t. I turned to look at the women and saw all of them staring back at me, eyes wide and jaw opened in such distortion that it looked as though it would dislocate. Then they began to scream, a sound much worse than anything the wind could make.
Fuck this—I sprinted back towards the apartment, ignoring how heavy my legs felt. In a blink I was back in my bed. I wasn’t quite sure how I got there, or how long it had taken me to get there, but all was quiet outside. I snuggled under the covers, grateful for the evening to be over. Just as I was about to close my eyes, I saw my closet door creak open. Out stepped a little boy in his pajamas, blonde hair and blue eyes—I know him, how do I know him? Before I could say anything, he opened his mouth in the same manner that the wild women did and let out a bone chilling scream. I covered my ears but I didn’t need to, it was over before it began. The boy started convulsing and fell to the ground like a rock. It took a full 5 seconds before my brain put the pieces together that he was having a seizure.
I leaped out of bed, “Shit! SHIT! Somebody help me! I NEED HELP!” I yelled and yelled for what felt like forever, but nobody came. I tried to recall all of my first aid and CPR training, but my mind was blank. When the seizure ended, I watched life bleed from the boy’s eyes. When he stilled in my arms, I heard my bedroom door open. It was one of the wild women. With glazed eyes, she brought two more children—her children—into my room and guided them to a seat on the floor. My skin grew slick with sweat—what the fuck. One by one, the wild women kept returning with the children who lived in the apartment complex, until no more abled bodies could fit in the room. I tried to talk, tried to scream, tried to ask them what they were doing; but nothing came out. Once the room was full, I heard the lock on the outside of the door click—shit. At that instant, all of the childrens’ eyes widened and their jaws extended.
“NO!” I screamed, but it was no use. I jolted awake.


It was July 3rd, 2018. My husband, Kyle, and I were driving across country with our two large dogs in a half-cab Toyota Tacoma, moving from Northern New Hampshire to Central Oregon. On our fourth day of travel—out of a week long planned journey—we were headed for the much anticipated, Bozeman, Montana. We had left the Badlands early that morning, making a few pit stops along the way. I took the liberty of snoozing in the passenger seat when the sights weren’t as inspiring, and woke up when we were somewhere in Wyoming.